Page MenuHomePhabricator

Personalized praise improvements for Flagged revisions
Open, MediumPublic

Description

User Story

As a Mentor at a wiki that utilizes Flagged revisions, I want to know the status of my mentees edits, because then I can decide if they are praiseworthy.

Background

In a Community consultation about Personalized Praise ideas, a community member mentioned:

On Arabic Wikipedia, and other wikis with Flagged Revisions, it would be ideal if mentors could see not only the number of edits a user had completed, but also more details on the review status of edits.

The personalized praise idea is part of a larger Growth team Positive Reinforcement effort.

Designs

Personalized praise designs on Figma

Personalized praise_ Flagged revs (1).png (517×448 px, 39 KB)

Design notes:

  • If we can link pending and validated revisions to special pages, then numbers should be using Content-Progressive (#3366CC).
  • The 'pending revisions' icon is a new icon created for this task. SVG can be found below.
  • 'Validated revisions' is using the ArticleCheck icon.

SVG for Edit+Clock icon:

Acceptance Criteria:

Given I'm a mentor viewing my Mentor dashboard from a Wiki that uses Flagged Revisions,
When I have a mentee suggested for Praise,
Then I can see the mentee's: Total edits, Pending revisions, and Validated edits

Event Timeline

@Dyolf77_WMF - Please let us know if you have any feedback on this design.

@JFernandez-WMF - In the design I notice that most of the numbers aren't blue/linked, but assuming we can easily link to a filtered view of the mentee's Pending revisions or Validated edits, I'm assuming we should do that, correct?

@Dyolf77_WMF - Please let us know if you have any feedback on this design.

Thanks, the shape of the clock on the pencil (pending edits) seems too confusing to me, is it a dot, a clock, extension on the pencil. Do you think an{F37113069} hour glass is less confusing?

In T340154#8957309, @Dyolf77_WMF wrote:
Thanks, the shape of the clock on the pencil (pending edits) seems too confusing to me, is it a dot, a clock, extension on the pencil. Do you think an{F37113069} hour glass is less confusing?

Thanks for the feedback @Dyolf77_WMF !
I'm open to an hour glass icon rather than the pencil+clock icon, but let's default to whatever design thinks is best here. @JFernandez-WMF - thoughts?

@JFernandez-WMF - In the design I notice that most of the numbers aren't blue/linked, but assuming we can easily link to a filtered view of the mentee's Pending revisions or Validated edits, I'm assuming we should do that, correct?

Thanks Kirsten, yes definitely if we can link it to a special page (I think Pending revisions can be linked, but not sure about Validated revisions) then numbers should be blue - I'll update the task with that info.

I'm open to an hour glass icon rather than the pencil+clock icon, but let's default to whatever design thinks is best here. @JFernandez-WMF - thoughts?

Thanks @Dyolf77_WMF for the feedback! We don't have an hourglass icon at the moment in the design system, so that would mean creating the icon from scratch. Maybe we can leave the edit+clock icon for now, and if any more significant feedback comes up about it being confusing, we can consider an hourglass design?