Page MenuHomePhabricator

Android Nearby/Places future ideas
Open, LowPublic

Description

The ideas below include suggestions from a share-out with the Wikimedia Design Team:

  • Branding: It makes sense to keep it unified as Places (not nearby) since the feature allows searching anywhere and not just places nearby. Renaming the Android feature when bringing it back will also help users understand it’s (literal) greater scope of use. Else a different feature name, “Maps” “ for both apps?
  • Connecting maps + lists: Given a list (e.g. Unesco World Heritage monuments”), visualize their items on a map. Highlight in the map those items that are part of one of your lists (a related idea that Google Maps does is to allow people to set an emoji for their lists of places so that they are highlighted in the general map). Also, it makes it easier to add map items to a list.
  • Connecting maps + (micro) contributions:
    • E.g. places without a picture. Articles you edited recently (or in your lists) lacking geographic position that can be added.
    • The Commons app has the feature to add an image to a place without a picture and could be used as inspiration.
    • Micro contributions and template support within articles that can increase editor awareness.
  • Expand filtering:
    • Explore indications and filtering for Saved, Watched, Open in tab, Search history on the map
    • Add filter what you see on the map, e.g. see articles in X collection.
  • Add Places to main Wikipedia search: Could we add places search to the main Wikipedia search and e.g. provide an option to filter directly from there? The current design for namespaces filtering (User: Portal: Help:) at the bottom of the search could be leveraged.
  • Color palette: Curious about the color palette used for your Mapbox or the rationale for those – given that Google Maps recently changed their colors (more in line with Apple) +1AA
  • Notifications: Use notifications to show the user some special places they are nearby. Not all, so it doesn't flood with notifications, but a few important ones. Maybe as a "travel mode" that you turn on when you go visit a new place, so it's like a tour guide telling you about the history of the places you are near.
  • Cultural routes: What about making a cultural route that people can use, almost like Google Maps, to connect a few places (with articles) and give the user a route to follow? See this as a very "touristy" feature.
  • Leverage AR/VR: Regarding future possibilities, as some big maps players are already leveraging AR/VR technology, would it be possible to plug-in this data in their existing system rather than building our own?
  • Explore feed: How could Places be integrated into the existing Explore feed card stack? What brings added value?
  • Space: It would be neat to see articles in space/solar system

Event Timeline

JTannerWMF added subscribers: ARamadan-WMF, JTannerWMF.

@ARamadan-WMF can you please add these points to mediawiki so that we can get feedback from members fo the community on some of these ideas.

I like Connecting maps + lists. Please see the related task T360197 where I noted Maybe at a later point this could better integrate with WikiVoyage as well as with articles about certain subjects (for example an article about greenspaces in a region could embed the filtered Places map showing only these particular items)

Connecting maps + (micro) contributions: seems more like that should be about Commons. One could however include the Commons' needed photos map and/or link some times to the Commons app (I think it still needs a few changes before it should be made more popular such as a Home feed and the ability to watch videos). Just as a note: the media gaps are largely in illustrations – lots of images are needed there but not so many photos at this point or when photos are needed it's usually not specific to any place (but e.g. a photo illustrating the Mediterranean diet of which there is 1 or 2 photos).

Expand filtering: also sounds very relevant to the task I linked above. However, I don't understand what you mean with the "Explore indications …" sentence. Please really do check out the other issue because I think the Places feature is not really useful in practice before this and 1 other issue are implemented.

Notifications Don't think that's a good idea for now – instead make it possible for the user to filter out uninteresting places and incorporate indicators of relevance such as WikiProject ratings, pageviews, etc that indicate some place is important or interesting. One can check the app often and quickly see nearby places, this is better than notifications of usually irrelevant/uninteresting random things (which additionally would require lots of development to make these interesting at least from time to time). One could instead add a feature to put items on your travel plan or sth like that so you only see these dots when opening the saved/bookmarked Places map and can e.g. go from one place to the next or find the nearest saved dot to your current location. Cultural routes could be implemented via enabling sharing of bookmarked/saved Places maps.

Leverage AR/VR don't know what you mean – this would be a task for those other projects if they are to use that data and other projects' AR/VR are not open content etc and shouldn't be included in a Wikimedia app.