Page MenuHomePhabricator

Determine integrity of Reply Tool diffs at ar/cs/hu wikis
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

This task is about inspecting diffs created by the Reply Tool once it's been made available to all users at Arabic, Czech and Hungarian Wikipedias by default.

Background

T249394 makes it so the Reply Tool is available to all users, logged in and out, at the Arabic, Czech and Hungarian Wikipedias by default. In doing so, it is more likely people will use the Reply Tool on pages they haven't before.

To ensure the Reply Tool behaves as we expect it to in these hypothetically new circumstances, we will review the diffs the tool creates that make any changes to pages beyond adding the contents of what people compose in their comments.

Timing

This task should be worked on within 1 week of T249394 being resolved.

Done

  • Any instances of Reply Tool edits causing changes other than content being added to the page are documented on this ticket

Event Timeline

ppelberg claimed this task.

Done

  • Any instances of Reply Tool edits causing changes other than content being added to the page are documented on this ticket

We ended up piloting a "Chore Wheel Experiment" wherein each member of the team took turns inspecting https://dtcheck.toolforge.org/dtstats.html and filing separate tasks for instances of corruption (e.g. T265094)