Page MenuHomePhabricator

Geoline via QID renders empty map
Open, Needs TriagePublicBUG REPORT

Description

See the example in this section, 2nd example titled "Köpenicker Straße in Berlin-Mitte/Kreuzberg"

Bildschirmfoto 2022-06-23 um 09.38.08.png (958×858 px, 41 KB)

The user was trying to add external data to the map, using the QID Q1796552 (Köpenicker Straße), but the map renders as empty. The full size map is wrong as well.

Note: Apparently, the OSM object consists of several geolines.

Event Timeline

There are currently 27 individual ways tagged as wikidata=Q1796552 (overpass query). Individually tagged ways, as opposed to relation members, got lost via geoline last year, see T288400.

Thanks, @Pikne! Do you happen to know: If a relation was created and tagged with Q1796552, would that QID need to be removed from all the individual ways?

If a relation was created and tagged with Q1796552, would that QID need to be removed from all the individual ways?

I suppose it'd be cleaner not to duplicate these links for a relation and its members. Though, I don't know if any OSM community guideline explicitly requires this.

Anyway, it should work without creating a relation, too. It'd be nice if WMDE can weigh in and help fix this.