Page MenuHomePhabricator

Render math markup in query service
Closed, ResolvedPublic


The query result should render math rather than displaying the data source

Event Timeline

Restricted Application added subscribers: Zppix, Aklapper. · View Herald Transcript

I used the rest interface to get closer to the origin of the problem:
Formulae are returned as

           <binding name='formula'>
                       <literal datatype=''>>&lt;math xmlns="" display="block"&gt;

which does not seem reasonable.
Where does the literal, and with the datatype attribute come from?
Is there a chance to fix that within the math extension?

Maybe the relevant code is

		$writer->say( $propertyValueNamespace, $propertyValueLName )
			->value( $mml, '' );

Is there a vagrant role that creates an Wikidata Query Service for testing?

Can it be that the title is misleading?
You want the math to be rendered in the table and other?

This is the place where you could change the rendering:

@Jonas thank you. After your comment, that was very helpful for me, it turns out that the title is misleading;-)

And yes. Math should be rendered in that table.

For the implementation I would add


extend the case statement with

 html = data;

Is it really that simple?

Yes, this should work :)
Thank you for your effort!

Doesn't html need to be a JQuery object? data is only string.

@Jonas do you have an idea how to test this change?
I have set up a vagrant test instance at wmflabs
But the information at is quite brief;-)

Thanks for your pull request, but this is just a mirror, please submit your patch here:

Just checkout the repo and open index.html that's it.

Jonas renamed this task from Wikidata label service should render math to Render math markup in query service.Jul 20 2016, 4:21 PM
Jonas updated the task description. (Show Details)

Change 300055 had a related patch set uploaded (by Physikerwelt):
Display MathML in the table view

Change 300055 merged by jenkins-bot:
Display MathML in the table view

We have a test instance at, where we could test things. It runs on Wikidata data so should be good for testing.

There's also role::wdqs role which allows to deploy in labs, but there are a bunch of manual steps - you have to check out WDQS deploy repo manually (scap doesn't work that well in labs IIRC) and then manually load data. Ping me if you need help with that, it's not hard but needs some manual steps now.

Smalyshev triaged this task as Medium priority.

Ah, it works for me now - meaning it displays something like:

{\displaystyle x:y:z\longrightarrow x^{-1}:y^{-1}:z^{-1}}

Is this how it's supposed to work?

Oh, cool. Looks like it's my browser that is missing math... I don't see it in Chrome, but Safari works just fine. Great then. Will be deployed on production next deployment window (Monday).

Unfortunately only works in some browsers:

On we have png fallback for this, I am not sure if it is necessary here.

It's still an improvement for some browsers, but a PNG fallback would be nice I think.