Page MenuHomePhabricator

Conduct heuristic evaluation of image search and insert flow in the VisualEditor
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Evaluate the image search and insert flow for usability, and share any findings to support iteration (if needed). Once evaluation is complete, we will create a report with screen shots (if needed) and share with the team.

Event Timeline

aripstra claimed this task.
aripstra raised the priority of this task from to Medium.
aripstra updated the task description. (Show Details)

@Daisy and I did the heuristic, and now Daisy is working on creating the findings deck. We published a stub describing this research here. This is where the findings will be published after we share out with the team.

Daisy and I did the heuristic, and now Daisy is working on creating the findings deck. We published a stub describing this research here.

Turns out there are several projects having to do with uploading images to wikipedia articles:

  1. image uploading of an image from commons to wiki page (what we did this heuristic on)
  2. inline editing of image comments and alignment - there are designs, but it is not implemented (AFAIK)
  3. Uploading image from user's computer to commons for using in a wikipedia article right away. (being implemented)

@Prtksxna (Prateek Saxena) adding you as I hear you are working on some of this too. Please let us know if we can do a heuristic on either number 2 or 3 listed above, and how that might be done prior to release (if possible).

I am a bit confused. I should be able to help, but a few clarifications first.

  1. image uploading of an image from commons to wiki page (what we did this heuristic on)

Do you mean to say using an image from commons? I don't think uploading would be the right word here. Also, the Heuristic Evaluation of image upload… page says:

Evaluate the usability of the image uploader within visual editor. It has been released to production…

As far as I know, there is no image uploader within VE in production right now.

  1. Uploading image from user's computer to commons for using in a wikipedia article right away. (being implemented)

This is being worked on at https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/#/c/240116/. What infrastructure do you currently have? Is it possible for you to check out this and a few other patches on a mediawiki installation somewhere?

The new uploading code is now live at http://en.wikipedia.beta.wmflabs.org/ and will be live at production wikis next week (Thursday for Wikipedias).

The results of this research are now published on mediawiki. I'd like to note that is the evaluation of the search and insert flow and not the upload flow which was added recently.

Prtksxna renamed this task from heuristic evaluation of image upload flow in the visual editor to Conduct heuristic evaluation of image search and insert flow in the VisualEditor.Nov 3 2015, 3:15 PM
Prtksxna updated the task description. (Show Details)