Per discussion, we should show current map zoom level in the edit preview and VE edit and VE dialog modes.
Description
Details
Subject | Repo | Branch | Lines +/- | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Show current zoom in edit preview & VE mode | mediawiki/extensions/Kartographer | master | +85 -10 |
Related Objects
Event Timeline
Dialog maybe, but the edit node should as close to the read mode rendering as possible.
Change 309349 had a related patch set uploaded (by JGirault):
Show current zoom in edit preview & VE mode
Suggesting:
- Edit Preview
- VE mode
EDIT: I noticed the capital to Zoom was missing, I added it.
Question: should we allow to edit the map position by coordinates/zoom within VE, as suggested in T133814, or should it be read-only, as suggested in the patch above?
I think having 3 boxes for zoom/lat/long is such a rare usecase that we can safely postpone it for now. Maybe eventually we will allow a single field that gets automatically parsed (so a user can copy/paste it from somewhere else) - much nicer user experience, but I think it is a fairly low value at this point.
This feature is currently way too prominent for such advanced user information - and using a table in a callout is a very clunky way of presenting it.
Do you have suggestions for improvement?
This feature was requested by the community and no one has complained about the current implementation yet.
Nothing concrete yet :)
Maybe a link inside the map itself, or a small text overlay like the copyright notice.
Moving off the sprint board - the Discovery team won't be able to finish this work at this time.
So, whether we like the current implementation or not, they are clearly shown, since 2016, so this should probably be closed. If you want to discuss it, I've proposed changes to this interface as a part of T203473: Fix maps dialog in mobile visual editor .