Page MenuHomePhabricator

VisualEditor ignores editpage-head-copy-warn message
Open, Needs TriagePublicFeature

Description

Feature summary (what you would like to be able to do and where):
A notice in the "Publish changes" dialogue of the Visual Editor that states that edits violating copyright/unsourced edits will be reverted.

This is already present in the Wikitext editor ("Content that violates any copyrights will be deleted. Encyclopedic content must be verifiable through citations to reliable sources.", stored here)

Use case(s) (list the steps that you performed to discover that problem, and describe the actual underlying problem which you want to solve. Do not describe only a solution):

IP users often don't know that they have to include sources for everything they add.

Benefits (why should this be implemented?):

  • Will reduce number of reverts IPs recieve, making them more likely to contribute in the future.
  • Less work for patrollers.

Event Timeline

The existing one is from showHeaderCopyrightWarning in EditPage.php, which shows the editpage-head-copy-warn message.

I've previously raised a similar thing here. @Whatamidoing-WMF pointed out that there's already a notice of sorts for new editors trying out VisualEditor. We made some adjustments to the wording, stored here (see the talk page), so I'm not sure there's all that much else to do.

As a suggested avenue for future development, it'd be nice if tools like Twinkle/RedWarn linked to the how-to-add-citations page when reverted unsourced material added by new editors.

We made some adjustments to the wording, stored here (see the talk page), so I'm not sure there's all that much else to do.

The message cited in task description additionally concerns copyrights, linking to Wikipedia:Copyright violations page in enwiki, while this Cite tool popup text only urges users to cite sources.

New/careless users often copy and paste, or alter the source material only a little, and hence violate copyrights (no matter whether they cite sources or not). WikiEditor displays associated warning message at the top of WikiEditor and always (not only in one-time pop-up). I don't think there is less reason to display this important message prominently in VisualEditor.

I'm not sure where in VisualEditor this message should be displayed, though. In "Save your changes" dialog above edit summary field perhaps?

Pikne renamed this task from Add notice to Visual Editor that unsourced edits may be reverted to VisualEditor ignores editpage-head-copy-warn message.Mar 4 2024, 4:46 PM
Pikne updated the task description. (Show Details)
Pikne updated the task description. (Show Details)

New/careless users often copy and paste, or alter the source material only a little, and hence violate copyrights (no matter whether they cite sources or not).

Aside: do you have links handy to 2-3 edits that show the above happening?

...I ask the above in an effort to add some evidence/context to the following row within mw:Edit check/Ideas: "Prompt people who are pasting text into an article to confirm the content is not at risk of creating a copyright violation."

Aside: do you have links handy to 2-3 edits that show the above happening?

In enwiki you can look for examples in maintenance categories like this, or look in deletion log for speedy deletion/redaction reasons G12 and RD1. Recent log entries refer to e.g. this page and this page where copyright violations were redacted today.