Page MenuHomePhabricator

Enable ReplyTool and New Topic Tool by default on ruwiki
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Related Objects

Event Timeline

Iniquity changed the task status from Open to Stalled.Jul 4 2022, 2:56 AM
Iniquity created this task.

Stalled before community discussion.

During the discussion, it turned out that it is not yet possible to connect external gadgets to the DT toolbar: T265981: Provide an API to hook into new reply editor. This can be critical as chrome makes cyrillic links unreadable and and Russian has a different typography than default.

Iniquity changed the task status from Stalled to Open.Aug 9 2022, 1:09 PM

Consensus received, you can turn it on! :) A few notes:

  1. We keep the current * setting. We do not use :.
  2. We really need T313165: Allow posting new sections to top of page on a per-page basis by DiscussionTools (all our forum use this style of new threads) and T265981: Provide an API to hook into new reply editor, but this tasks not blockers.

Consensus received, you can turn it on! :) A few notes:

  1. We keep the current * setting. We do not use :.
  2. We really need T313165: Allow posting new sections to top of page on a per-page basis by DiscussionTools (all our forum use this style of new threads) and T265981: Provide an API to hook into new reply editor, but this tasks not blockers.

@Iniquity this is great news to hear! Thank you for all of the effort you put into starting and facilitating this discussion with volunteers at ru.wiki [i]

A couple of comments and a follow-up question to what you shared in T311967#8140322:

  1. You can expect the Editing Team to implement the API T265981 describes. I expect us to be able to prioritize work on implementing this in the next month or so.
  2. I do not expect the Editing Team to be able to prioritize work on T313165 in the near-term

Question: assuming the above sounds good to you, do you have any preferences for when the Reply and New Topic Tool deployment happens?

While you think about the above, I'm going to:

  • Talk with the engineers on the team to learn what – if any – changes are necessary to ensure the Reply Tool uses * to indent comments people post with it. I think the answer here is "no changes are needed" and I'd like to confirm.
  • Revise the scope of T297410 so that it includes the deployments of both the Reply and New Topic Tools

i. https://ru.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Википедия:Форум/Предложения&oldid=124698993#Включение_части_функций_«Инструментов_обсуждения»_по_умолчанию

  1. You can expect the Editing Team to implement the API T265981 describes. I expect us to be able to prioritize work on implementing this in the next month or so.

Thanks!

  1. I do not expect the Editing Team to be able to prioritize work on T313165 in the near-term

It's just that this thing would be very useful to many wikis, I hope it will be implemented in the future.

Question: assuming the above sounds good to you, do you have any preferences for when the Reply and New Topic Tool deployment happens?

Anytime you want :)

  • Talk with the engineers on the team to learn what – if any – changes are necessary to ensure the Reply Tool uses * to indent comments people post with it. I think the answer here is "no changes are needed" and I'd like to confirm.

Can you consult also about this question plz: T298932#8115366.

Question: assuming the above sounds good to you, do you have any preferences for when the Reply and New Topic Tool deployment happens?

Anytime you want :)

Understood! If all goes to plan, the Reply and New Topic Tools will become avail. this upcoming Wednesday, 17 August. I've revised T297410's task description to reflect this deployment date and the deployment of both the Reply and New Topic Tools.

  • Talk with the engineers on the team to learn what – if any – changes are necessary to ensure the Reply Tool uses * to indent comments people post with it. I think the answer here is "no changes are needed" and I'd like to confirm.

Can you consult also about this question plz: T298932#8115366.

It looks like Matmarex addressed this question in T259864#8149220 :)

Thank you! Looking forward to the 17th then :)

It works! Thanks! :)

Yay! Please let us know if you notice anything unexpected.

It works! Thanks! :)

Yay! Please let us know if you notice anything unexpected.

If anything happens, I'll be sure to let you know :)

stjn claimed this task.
stjn subscribed.

Half a year later, we can safely resolve this.