| kostajh | |
| Feb 14 2024, 9:04 AM |
| F55893422: image.png | |
| Wed, Jun 26, 12:11 PM |
| F55493339: image.png | |
| Thu, Jun 20, 11:38 AM |
There are at least three issues:
| Subject | Repo | Branch | Lines +/- | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Create a autocreate log when a temporary account is created on edit | mediawiki/core | master | +64 -6 |
| Status | Subtype | Assigned | Task | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| In Progress | Niharika | T324492 Temporary accounts - MVP | |||
| Open | None | T326816 Update features for temporary accounts | |||
| Open | KStoller-WMF | T326877 [Epic] Update Growth Team-owned products that may be affected by IP Masking | |||
| Open | None | T328718 [IP Masking] Do not show logged-in version of Special:CreateAccount page to temp accounts | |||
| Open | Dreamy_Jazz | T357498 Temp account creations do not appear in Special:Log |
Are you planning to work on this? Or do you want someone else to work on it? (AuthManager is owned by MediaWiki Platform, temporary users are owned by AHT and the account creation experience is owned by Growth so the ownership of tasks like this one is a bit unclear.)
a user account created by a temp account ( 15:40, 12 February 2024 User account Drw1234 talk contribs was created by ~2024-600 talk contribs)
As @Bugreporter pointed out on the other task, this is a privacy leak (or would be if the feature were in production).
Looking at https://de.wikipedia.beta.wmflabs.org/wiki/Spezial:Logbuch?type=newusers&user=&page=&wpdate=&tagfilter=&wpfilters[]=newusers&wpFormIdentifier=logeventslist&uselang=en, I would expect to see the temp account I created.
Instead, I only see:
- an autocreated temp account (21:17, 12 February 2024 User account *Unregistered 35214 talk contribs was created automatically )
This part seems to be working as expected. Or is that a different temp account?
That part (autocreated temp account) does work as expected.
If you want to work on it, we'd welcome your support (cc @Tchanders).
@kostajh @Tgr I believe this is covered by this Growth-Team task: T328718
Do not show the unregistered account that created the new account in Special:Log&page=&tagfilter=&type=newusers
@RHo Have I got that right?
Ah, this does indeed appear to be part of T328718: [IP Masking] Do not show logged-in version of Special:CreateAccount page to temp accounts. I'll make this as a subtask of that one.
On the beta wikis, there is a entry showing the temporary account on wikis other than that used to make the first edit. For example, when I make an edit on cswiki and then open dewiki there is a log entry as follows:
The "Type of account creation" menu should have an entry for temp accounts
@kostajh I am not sure what the need for a separate option in this dropdown menu, and which of the logs should go there.
I ask this because, as shown in T357498#9926151 if a user logged in to a temporary account visits a different wiki then this appears in the Automatic creation list. As such, some of these logs are already in that section and so would deliberately need to be moved.
My suggestion would be to keep all temporary account creation logs in the Automatic creation section, considering that the banner describes a temporary account will be created for you which suggests to me that this is an automated process separate to the user making an edit.
On the beta wikis, there is a entry showing the temporary account on wikis other than that used to make the first edit. For example, when I make an edit on cswiki and then open dewiki there is a log entry as follows:
This is what we call CentralAuth (SUL) autocreation. Autocreation has multiple meanings, this is one, creating a temporary account on first edit may be one, and another kind is autocreation via external auth extension (such as what Wikitech currently does).
On the beta wikis, there is a entry showing the temporary account on wikis other than that used to make the first edit. For example, when I make an edit on cswiki and then open dewiki there is a log entry as follows:
This is what we call CentralAuth (SUL) autocreation. Autocreation has multiple meanings, this is one, creating a temporary account on first edit may be one, and another kind is autocreation via external auth extension (such as what Wikitech currently does).
Sure. I think maybe at some point this log did not work for temporary accounts based on the task description, but it is at least now working.
For the time being I will reject the idea of creating a separate dropdown option for temporary account creations, and instead ensure they are visible when selecting the Automatic creation menu option (or also the All option).
Change #1049923 had a related patch set uploaded (by Dreamy Jazz; author: Dreamy Jazz):
[mediawiki/core@master] Create a autocreate log when a temporary account is created on edit