Page MenuHomePhabricator

Pre-deployment QA Edit Cards v2.0
Open, Needs TriagePublic

Description

Task overview

Before we deploy v2.0 of the mobile Edit Cards [1] (T225725), we should QA them to make sure they work as we and contributors will expect them to.

Where to test

Once, T226679 is resolved, Edit Cards v2.0 can be tested on the prototype server: http://visualeditor-prototype.wmflabs.org/wiki/Pride_and_Prejudice

"Done"

  • The following adding and editing link workflows function properly
    • Add a new internal link
    • Add a new external link
    • Remove an existing link
    • Change an existing internal link's target to another internal link
    • Change an existing link's label text

  1. "Edit Cards" as defined in our VE developer glossary

Event Timeline

Restricted Application added a subscriber: Aklapper. · View Herald TranscriptApr 17 2019, 10:19 PM
ppelberg renamed this task from pre-deployment QA "adding/modifying citations" to Mobile edit cards: pre-deployment QA "adding/modifying citations".Apr 17 2019, 10:20 PM
marcella moved this task from To Triage to Q4 on the VisualEditor board.May 15 2019, 4:02 PM
ppelberg renamed this task from Mobile edit cards: pre-deployment QA "adding/modifying citations" to Pre-deployment QA Edit Cards v2.0.Jul 3 2019, 5:15 AM
ppelberg updated the task description. (Show Details)
ppelberg updated the task description. (Show Details)
Ryasmeen added a subscriber: Ryasmeen.EditedJul 9 2019, 11:44 PM

@ppelberg: I am done doing Pre-deployment QA on Edit Cards v2.0. Have found couple of UX issues and I am going to make them as subtasks here for tracking.

Apart from the ones reported I have another observation about the workflow of adding label which I have not reported since I don't have a specific alternative suggestion. I feel when a user taps on the first pencil and it closes the Edit card and goes back to the page it's not quite apparent it's for changing the label. There is no visual clue other than the highlight (which also goes out of view, because of T227627) and the keyboard appearing. I understand that previously it used to be the same but we didn't have any explicit button on mobile to change the label, but now I feel there might be a user expectation for clearer indication of what it's for.

Also, once you are in that label editing mode, tapping on the link again and again does not bring back the edit card but keeps the user in that confusing stage unless they click somewhere else and then again click back on that link. I can report this as a bug if you think it's valid.

ppelberg reassigned this task from ppelberg to Ryasmeen.Jul 11 2019, 4:10 AM

@ppelberg: I am done doing Pre-deployment QA on Edit Cards v2.0. Have found couple of UX issues and I am going to make them as subtasks here for tracking.

You filing T227630 T227627 T227628 is a big help, Rummana – thank you!

Apart from the ones reported I have another observation about the workflow of adding label which I have not reported since I don't have a specific alternative suggestion. I feel when a user taps on the first pencil and it closes the Edit card and goes back to the page it's not quite apparent it's for changing the label. There is no visual clue other than the highlight (which also goes out of view, because of T227627) and the keyboard appearing. I understand that previously it used to be the same but we didn't have any explicit button on mobile to change the label, but now I feel there might be a user expectation for clearer indication of what it's for.
Also, once you are in that label editing mode, tapping on the link again and again does not bring back the edit card but keeps the user in that confusing stage unless they click somewhere else and then again click back on that link. I can report this as a bug if you think it's valid.

Your experience is absolutely valid...please file this too. In fact, @Trizek mentioned something similar.

And in general, if you find something to be unclear/confusing/frustrating, I hope you continue to speak up ^ _ ^. We've been so close to this work that it's a treat to find about experiences like this.
cc @Esanders @iamjessklein

Trizek edited subscribers, added: Trizek-WMF; removed: Trizek.Jul 11 2019, 6:51 AM

@ppelberg: I am done doing Pre-deployment QA on Edit Cards v2.0. Have found couple of UX issues and I am going to make them as subtasks here for tracking.

You filing T227630 T227627 T227628 is a big help, Rummana – thank you!

Apart from the ones reported I have another observation about the workflow of adding label which I have not reported since I don't have a specific alternative suggestion. I feel when a user taps on the first pencil and it closes the Edit card and goes back to the page it's not quite apparent it's for changing the label. There is no visual clue other than the highlight (which also goes out of view, because of T227627) and the keyboard appearing. I understand that previously it used to be the same but we didn't have any explicit button on mobile to change the label, but now I feel there might be a user expectation for clearer indication of what it's for.
Also, once you are in that label editing mode, tapping on the link again and again does not bring back the edit card but keeps the user in that confusing stage unless they click somewhere else and then again click back on that link. I can report this as a bug if you think it's valid.

Your experience is absolutely valid...please file this too. In fact, @Trizek mentioned something similar.

@ppelberg: filed the above as T228220.

Trizek removed a subscriber: Trizek.Jul 17 2019, 7:22 AM