In T355312#9503772, @stjn wrote:

Doing changes without asking the communities purely because they don’t have a lot of intadmins is, frankly, not justified at all. Hopefully wikis listed voice their clear opposition to this planned switch.

In T332774#8717835, @TheDJ wrote:

This seems like a recent change... it used to be that only the groups used on the page by the map link/mapframe functions would be listed, but it seems now all categories that are defined are added to the list even when unused, making it very very long ? This might be due to a change in how the group parameter is being handled by the parser function ?

Seems like a potential hackathon project to me. If it's not, feel free to remove the project tag.

From the description:

VE changes (wish) needs updating: https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Help:VisualEditor/Maps/de, maybe link to this page from the Kartographer help page?

This page is already linked from the general Kartographer help page, see the blue box in the top right corner, so I'll remove that part from the description.

(Not sure whether to open a new ticket for these questions:)

In T313010#8501974, @WMDE-Fisch wrote:

The auto position can not be set from nothing.

Shouldn't the position come from the QID, Q41437865?

Create a new section "Points" after "Mask layer" (nice to have)

IMHO, it makes more sense to add the example of geopoints via QID to the existing section "Via Wikidata ID" and the example of a query to the existing section "Via Wikidata query"

In T312752#8231612, @WMDE-Fisch wrote:

Review summary:
Test page looks good. Can be used in production when we deploy. One follow up issue with the icons not loading initially will be dealt with in a separate ticket.

@thiemowmde Just to be sure: So we'll actually be updating the icons in Kartographer to Maki 7.2? I'm asking because that info will be in announcements and on our project pages.

@lilients_WMDE Can you provide a few screenshot to illustrate what this is about?

The error also occurs with geoline objects, example: Cookstraße

In T312913#8097787, @thiemowmde wrote:

• I also have seen empty results like {"type":"FeatureCollection","features":[]} but currently can't reproduce this any more.

In T312913#8093961, @thiemowmde wrote:

As of now, the 1st example works for me in both the thumbnail view as well as fullscreen.

On my device, the problem currently exists:

Potentially related? https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roberto-Burle-Marx-Stätte#Beschreibung

Weirdly, the article now shows the correct shape, but the full size view does not:

More examples that are not working at this moment:

Another example: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tideelbe_von_R%C3%B6nne_bis_Bunth%C3%A4user_Spitze

This might be what is behind T312950: The issue there seems to be currently gone, but I expect it might come and go.

See also https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C5%92il_(Aumance)
The map was displayed yesterday, today it's an empty frame:

Several issues that are probably related to this bug are collected in this task: T310289

Another example: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iguaçu

Potentially related to the caching issues in T313010 and T312950#8076956?

I noticed another caching bug, maybe related as well? T313010

In T312950#8076956, @TheDJ wrote:

Weird. Seems like an initial error state + caching issue ? I opened the page, image missing, I open the inspector, grabbed the links from the element, opened those SEPARATELY, the image loaded, refresh the page, the page has the image....

Another example: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benutzer:Albatros_58/Karten_2#Kopiervorlage_3

Weirdly enough, it does work now., but it didn't up to a few minutes ago. I don't know if some issue was just fixed or if the rendering is unstable.

In T300040#8071498, @thiemowmde wrote:

• animal-shelter was added later, in version 7.2.
• camera → attraction are the same icon, just renamed.
• Same with disability → wheelchair.
• park shows a different tree now. Not a pine-like but a maple-like tree. I missed that before. What actually happend are these renames: park → park-alt1 and park2 → park.

BTW, I noticed that the icon set I could download on mapbox.com had the icon animal-shelter, but the 7.0.0 icon set on Github doesn't. Should we add that icon as well?
Note that it doesn't appear in this overview either: https://labs.mapbox.com/maki-icons/