|UsersMultiselectWidget||APISandbox||CategorySelector||MWCategoryWidget||Category lists||Active filter area|
|Project||MediaWiki-extensions-Newsletter||MediaWiki-extensions-ApiSandbox||UploadWizard||VisualEditor||ContentTranslation (CX 2)||Edit-Review-Improvements-RC-Page|
|OOUI Widget||MW UsersMultiselectWidget <- MenuTagMultiselectWidget||CapsuleMultiselectWidget||mwe-upwiz-categoriesDetailsWidget <- CapsuleMultiselectWidget||CapsuleMultiselectWidget||MenuTagMultiselectWidget||MenuTagMultiselectWidget|
|Edit||(not directly from the widget, need to open the dropdown T67518)|
|Remove||(not directly from the widget, need to open the dropdown)|
|Click for more||(opens the category page)||(opens a dropdown with options)|
|Separate input widget|
- The circled X to remove the tag is too prominent. The main purpose of the tag is to communicate its content, removing it should be a discoverable action but not the main focus of attention. Using a regular "x" would reduce the visual weight, making it less prominent and more consistent with other components. – See proposal in F5667703. Fixed in v0.19.5
- The vertical space for the tags and the container make the components feel a bit cluttered by so many lines together with not much space around them.While keeping the components compact, they can benefit from some extra space. – Got increased to standard widget 32px height.
- The overhauled tag component is so much bigger that, when part of an input field, it heightens the field to 40+px. All other input field/dropdown components (only exception SelectFieldWidget with drop area) are at 32px height. See M101 – Declined. TagMultiselectWidget offers a variety of ways to construct it's UI and we stay with the multitude of options right now.
- The whole editing pattern is not clearly at stake now, but seems like a major pain: No in-place editing of tags, but changing order on clicking the tag. RCFilters once again has a different take there. – TagMultiselectWidget has improved the editing a lot.
Further issues filed as sub-tasks for now