Searched For: deletedtopic
o replicate the issue** (include links if applicable):
* Create a topic
* Open a new tab, and delete that topic
* On the original tab, try to edit the title of that deleted topic
**What happens?**:
Received an … of (not localized) "permissions".
minimal examples: https://test.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topic:Xbm9rkr52tr84rpj, https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Xblss3eypj6i1ih7
The messages "This topic was hidden by 1234qwer1234qwer4" and "This topic was deleted by Clump" show the username as p … example.
{F36551793}
{F36551794}
Admins can see deleted topics by visiting the Topic page.
Right now, the page looks just like any other topic page.
We should add a header that shows:
* the topic has been deleted
* who deleted it
* when it was deleted
* reason for deletion
Note that some topics will be deleted as the result of somebody deleti … d deletion reason on each of the deleted topic pages.
When you delete or suppress a Flow topic, there are surprising effects for that topic's posts in the history.
**Deleting a topic**:
BanjoDog created a topic called "Cats and dogs", with one post.
Admin DannyH deleted the topic using the dropdown menu on the topic header.
Looking at the history … (admin) sees:
The line about the topic creation is marked as deleted. This is correct.
The line about … -admin) sees:
The line about the …
new topics. Per https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T90974#1259120 .
Split from {T116058}
After a topic is deleted, 'changed the topic title' actions should not be pre … nt/Watchlist/User contributions .
1) When deleteing flow talk page, included topics are not deleted and can be found on [[special:allpages]]
2) deleting topic marks this topic as deleted, but still can be found on [[spe … ould be marked e.g. by italics )
1. Create a topic, perform some actions - e.g. ren … summary, resolve.
2. Delete the topic.
3. Go to View history and click on the topic link in the actions that are done before deleting the topic: e.g. in the screenshot such lin … ed rectangle.
**Note:** Resolve topic action does not indicate that the topic was subsequently deleted - notice that there is no cross- … e timestamp.
{F4690092}
4. The topic permalink will be displayed and … ights require to post summary to …
m9&action=history
Possible solutions:
- Show "xxx records about deleted topics not shown" on history
- … re always be 50 visible records
I've no idea what "Hide topic" and "Delete topic" are supposed to do differently. … one, make it more discoverable)?
lude links if applicable):
* Visit https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Xcssko66tj8vn22v?useskin=timeles … on IRC) narrowed this down to a deleted Structured Discussions topic that displays the deletion log. … n https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Xcsralcp1d63r6vd?useskin=timeles … (32dfa3c) 07:11, 13 February 2023
**Problem:** When a //globalsysop// global user deleted either (a) a StructuredDiscussions topic or (b) a post on a StructuredDiscussions topic page, they encountered the follo … ream extension bug per @RhinosF1.
For admin it's impossible hide the title of topic and if the topic is deleted the title is always visible. It' … I tried to hide and delete the topic but the title is always visible.
See also:
* {T103616}
e it makes sense that sysops should be able to see the contents of deleted topics, it doesn't make much sen … are able to see the contents of deleted posts in Flow as this doesn't ha … .159.63 (talk) commented on This topic was deleted by Glaisher ( <-- spam contents … kimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=60972
* On a wiki where you have the `flow-delete` right, create a test topic.
* Start the deletion dialog for that topic
* Try submitting without a summa … ld have happened instead?**:
The topic should be deleted without a summary, same as when … hout a summary, but not delete a topic on its talk page without one.
<flow-error-not-allowed-view-to-delete-topic> is in use but is missing.
https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Sdko6823xasjoj7x (logged out)
h … 0%B0:Sepbvqy8zb1kvctb (logged in)
@Quiddity deleted a test post I made on the sandbo … " (that was not part of the test topic I created) and instead of the topic name it says "This topic was deleted by Quiddity (WMF)". However, I believe the topic title is public information (eve … here's my description:
When a topic is suppressed and then unsuppres … suppression log say:
DannyH deleted topic "Topicname" in Talk:Sandbox (und … suppress)
DannyH suppressed …
Hiding, Deleting, or Suppressing a topic does not remove it from the ToC. … anything and the error "Rendered topic not found when attempting to scr … ding, Deleting, or Suppressing a topic should remove it from the ToC immediately.
Deleting the first comment of a topic (with no more comments) leaves the topic with zero comments. This is weird. The user that deleted the comment probably wanted to delete the whole topic.
I think that deleting the firs … comment should delete the entire topic. But maybe do that **only** if t … s the are no more comment of the topic. It may make sense to delete th … than one.
{F2619313}
{F2619315}
opiclist_loop.partial"]
```
Talk:ET5 is a protected page that was deleted - http://en.wikipedia.beta.wmfla … _loop.partial", 2 more… }
```
1. Resolve a topic (a topic has some comments)
2. Delete or … s all comments from the resolved topic - the resolved topic will display misleading link-li … F4426790}
Note:
If comments are deleted/suppressed on un-resolved topics … ave rights to see the info about deleted/suppressed comments.
1. A user receives an email about some updates on a topic summary:
{F4711144}
2. A topic was deleted.
3. A user clicks on link 'View … ta.wmflabs.org/w/index.php?title=Topic:Teq7g4yxw2d68xzj&action=compare- … permission
- does not display a topic title nor the Flow board title
… case with attempting to view a deleted topic via link from an email (a user clicks on 'View topic' from an email but the topic is …
plicate the issue** (include links if applicable):
* Create a Flow topic, hide the comment (post) and/or the topic; then unhide.
* Check the user l … ocal language with a link to the topic unhidden should have been displa … tly still seems to be impossible.
mplemented in {T90973} but seems to have broken since then.
E.g. I Deleted these 3 topics ([[https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Ss622zznkfihkz9d|one]], [[https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Ss5k346hg7m6nd1j|two]], [[https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Ss5jyp81khmcqapk|three]]), but n … 2314965 (real example: I've just deleted threats towards an editor and no … hose edits appear on my personal deleted contributions log, which as you … es no sense and is unnaceptable).…
licate the issue** (include links if applicable):
* Create a Flow topic, hide it or the comment (post).
… og, user contributions, and Flow topic history. Example: https://test.w … .wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Topic:Xbm9rkr52tr84rpj&action=history.
**What happens?**:
Topic history and contributions list h … the other log types listed there.
space=&hidelinks=1 while logged out
* Try to click the link to the topic or the post.
*
**What happens? … e/version, screenshots, etc.):
can now delete and suppress resolved topics, you can not hide them.
If a non-admin visits a deleted topic
they receive this error message: … kimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=62176
In other words: if I have a topic with a comment in it, bernie del … at comment, and S suppresses the topic, any attempt by an oversighter to view the topic involves opening the topic...and then having to individuall … up any individually suppressed, deleted or hidden comment.
Bah.
Hiding or Deleting or Suppressing a topic should nullify the status of the … in a cascading manner (hiding a topic does nothing to …
screenshot
Closing or hiding/restoring a topic, currently strikes out the entry … *: normal
**Attached**: {F13653}
The h1 heading just says "Topic on Talk:<Flow board name>", the same title as viewing the Topic itself.
It should be something like
"History of Topic on Talk:<Flow board name>"
or it could be
"History of Topic <topic title> on Talk:<Flow board name> … more useful.
- Doesn't match the Topic page heading (which doesn't include the topic title because it's repeated in the topic titlebar immediately below).
- C … the HTML <title> tag is just the …
Notification that says:
"Topic title / Username hid this topic on Talk:Boardname."
The notification links to the Topic page, which displays the message … the name of the user who hid the topic, and the stated reason for remov … ng it. Users can also unhide the topic from this page.
Use cases:
* … I am now being notified that the topic was removed, so that I can see t … who posted or replied to a good topic, which was removed by villains. … otified so that I can unhide the …
ixing two display modes:
> 1. Chronological
> 2. By (sub(sub(...)))topic
>
>I believe indentation should only be used to provide topic information, not chronological i … ing the position of replies in a topic, and would complicate the task of splitting a topic into subtopics). This is exactly … [ Subject ] [ Author ] [ Date ].
Hidden/deleted/suppressed topics that the user … unspecified
**Severity**: normal
On test2, as Selenium_user I deleted the first post on a topic, and 'Selenium user deleted a comment on "Topic name"' immediately showed up in Topic history (good). But then I deleted the topic itself, and this doesn't appear in Topic history, either for Selenium user or regular user (bad).
The topic is https://test2.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topic:S5v4yj8alfto9hw3?action=history
… anges.
(If you try to view this …
In betalabs search for - Talk:ET20 1 - the "Unknown topic" page is displayed:
{F12268959} … (redirects to the same "Unknown topic"), and "Delete, Move. Protect" o … hat happened to the page though.
you can compare the watched and unwatched topic stars with those at the top of t … ar is surrounded by gray things).
rst author> & <last author> + 2 others:
If an existing summary is deleted, the blank summary area should n … task was extracted from {T98929}
If a board is deleted, we probably want to hide all co … his:
{F2757892}
Boards are not deleted nearly as often as topics, but this is still an issue.
When reviewing a revision on the deleted Flow board (e.g. http://en.wikip … 09110}
Using a permalink for the topic on the deleted Flow board, a user may type some … d. See my comments on {T108762}.
1. In betalabs add or edit a topic summary.
2. Select the sorting o … as been selected already)
3. The topic with added/deleted summary will not be moved to the … them marked as 'Recently active topic'
l links if applicable):
* Go to some Flow discussion
* Delete some topic.
**What happens?**:
The 'cance … , etc**:
MediaWiki 1.37.0-wmf.16
cial:WhatLinksHere/Template:TH_question_page specifically line 14: Topic:S214uoczkp47cfsx (transclusion; … [ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topic:S214uoczkp47cfsx ]: 13:57, Septe … 10, 2014 Coren (talk | contribs) deleted a topic on Topic:S214uoczkp47cfsx (Test, borne ou … l thread.)
[19:32] <T13> Why are deleted topics still transcluding templa … s table. That'd be a mw bug imo.
description of the issue is moved to Comments.
Two cases - 1) a topic was deleted when another user attempt to post/add new topic 2) The Flow board (a page was deleted).
**The topic was deleted.**
- First user deletes a topic while another user was viewing the topic (the topic is displayed on the second user … econd user attempts to add a new topic or a new post. For a new topic the error message displays confu … VE pop-up, or 'Conversion from '…
want to match that functionality.
The feature is similar to Hide topic, and will use some similar eleme … " notice.
Requirements:
**Move topic as part of the action menu**
{F38375}
* User can select "Move topic" in the dropdown menu.
* The act … ols
-- Cancel (link)
-- Move topic (button)
* The user types the n … tions (and logging).
* The Move topic button is disabled until the use … 87}
* When the user clicks Move …
As an editor, I want to be able to
* Split off-topic Posts into a new Topic
* Move Posts from one Topic into a different (more relevant) Topic
* Merge duplicate topics
The destination topic might be on the same Board, or a …
* {T88140}
* {T88616}
* {T78253}
Delete a Flow post with a wikilink in the summary.
* Open the Flow topic history (and/or contributions) a … .wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Topic:Xbm9rkr52tr84rpj&action=history, … g entries do not exist (T328360).
k and see if they start
using them.
Say you want an article to be deleted. Start a thread with afd tag,
ex … ration-Team board
**See also**
* Topic on Talk:Flow: [[https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Stw9v96794a5emt5| what happened to 'tag' concept?]]
ussions (Flow) board with some topics
* delete the board
* visit a topic, logged in as a user with the right to view deleted Flow pages
Expected behavior: y … warning that you are looking at deleted (or inaccessible) content
Actual … ke it would if the board weren't deleted. Even commenting seems to be ena … on link - I might respond in the topic and have no idea that most parti … do Y" - and is not very helpful.)
e thread? Is it converted properly? Is the page taken over by Flow?
kind of criteria?
Ideas include:
- Aggregating on the date the topic was created for a given board
- Aggregating if that topic belongs to a certain category
… - Combinations of these criteria
Hello. If some vandalist creates a new topic in some talk page with agly cont … it's very good. But in flow, the topic name stays in page history and o … you, please fix this? Thank you.
rs have initiated discussions to [[ https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Wvqji3vfu2j1na7g | replace Flow … though. We also wouldn't retain deleted comments.
* Since Flow doesn't u … scussions/Deprecation
* {T325222}
f we can find or create a suitable test page)
* handling of hidden/deleted/suppressed comments/topics
* hug … mate of time needed per comment?
ry. There is no template and no category in the description and no Topic in the discussion.
Note: it see … related template in these pages.
* from one board to another. {T88140}
* **Move comments** within a topic. {T95118}
* **Filter topics on-p … as Resolved"
* **Human-readable topic … mp issues (T111596)
* Other post/topic interaction issues
** Allow IPs … * (e.g. T170330, and many others)
rent users and highlight the invisible effects (e.g., article X is deleted) but do not have real effect on …
{F183199}
{F183201}
{F183204}
*
* Submitter's recommendation (what do you propose be done?):
**
ow posts in people's contributions, and other logs. With the pages deleted and disabled with the kill switc … a message saying that it's been deleted. If the extension was completely … andles possible serious errors.
at is a problem (the real issue is whether there is some artifact).
hed after the end of the month. Time to fix this once and for all.
were deleting topics.
When I attempted to delete something already deleted (workflow rtqjfw4o2m1tfpxe), aft … st returns
{"flow":{"moderate-topic":{
"status":"error",
"result":{"topic":{"permissions":{"message":"Insu … on:
1 user creates a post in the topic
2 user changes this post
2 user … has been done before" or similar
onPermissionsTest.php:200
```
Maybe related:
* {T74367}
* {T70639}
lAuth data storage but I've found that it only contains `flow-lock-topic` and `flow-restore-topic`. The `lock` in `log_type` is no … describing if possible. Thanks.
d have messages for 'action-flow-edit-post', 'action-flow-suppress-topic', etc.
I added a bunch of comme … kimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=70497
Thread: https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Sami9qe4icwmyz4x
Post: https://w … .mediawiki.org/w/index.php?title=Topic:Sami9qe4icwmyz4x&topic_showPostI … .mediawiki.org/w/index.php?title=Topic:Sami9qe4icwmyz4x&topic_showPostI … er see on Special:Watchlist/raw: Topic:Sami9qe4icwmyz4x
The current Fl … add-extra-human-readable-text-to-topic-page-urls
* https://trello.com/c … 442-appearance-of-and-linking-to-topic-uuid
* {T71041}
* {T62663}
* https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/…
This topic has 10 posts, 7 of which were deleted. http://ee-flow.wmflabs.org/w/in … 75f47a334dffb6efa163e68c4ac
The topic titlebar says "10 comments", but … ecified
**Severity**: enhancement
---------------------
**Version**: master
**Severity**: enhancement
r decreases it), then I should get a Notification.
Eg. I hid this topic, and then another editor restored the topic, but I wasn't notified. https:// … ia_talk:Flow/Developer_test_page&topic%5BpostId%5D=051029058ef4f4a3d2e0 … 58ef4f4a3d2e090b11c2fb49a&action=topic-history
(I would have been noti … kimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=62612
Currently, I have no way of knowing if my Flow content was (hidden/deleted/suppressed).
If someone moderates a Topic or Post that I created, I should … kimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=61156
At https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Topic:S1h3933zeog0cpxe&action=history
… unspecified
**Severity**: normal
disabled, and Flow worked pretty well!
A few things I noticed:
* Topic title and post textareas don't h … w.base'.
* You can create a new topic with no title, server should pro … buttons overlap the post and the topic bar. Maybe these buttons could a … ut there's no indication of what topic it was in. This is Mingle card 3 … how the post in context within a topic, but I understand that's difficu … ion**: master
**Severity**: minor…
ternative, but I think the current design is problematic.
{F122323}
ntributions view on mw.org and see a revision that was reverted or deleted, I can see the name of the user who authored the reverted/deleted revision. If the revision was deleted, I see a strikethrough on the ti … indicating that the revision was deleted.
If I go to the RC, watchlist, … rname of a person whose post was deleted or suppressed, and a strikethrou … rson whose content was hidden or deleted (and suppressed? need to ping an … kimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=58016…
w/index.php?title=Special%3ALog&type=delete&user=Mattflaschen&page=Topic%3ASd8cifjpamo6hegb&year=&month=- … d name, but other times only the Topic page. It apparently never shows the topic title. See https://www.mediawik … .wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Topic:Sdf3qvfyxvn5r4lo&topic_showPostI … *See also**
* {T67878}
* {T59512}
s.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedie:Flow/Problémy|that feedback list]].
0}
Opening Special:WhatLinksHere does not make any problems. FYI.
See, for example, https://www.mediawiki.org/w/index.php?title=Topic:U8166u0ut3t00d20&action=history
rently, all permutations incorrectly use mw-ui-constructive:
Hide topic
Delete topic
Suppress topic
Hide post
Delete post
Suppress … ourse for concluded discussions).
looks like:
02:45, 21 February 2015 <logentry-lock-flow-lock-topic> (Lock action at 2015-02-20 09:4 … r (Talk | contribs) flow-restore-topic (Test unlock after refactoring) … dex.php?title=Special%3ALog&page=Topic%3ASntfxrjgf0wgz5o1
lism to the header of the Wikipedia:Village_Pump or Talk:Main_Page.
confusing with VE, but we should still consider the wikitext case.
sj2slbljkfplvy4i#flow-post-sj2slbljkfplvy4i
**See also**: {T96631}
ook at those two cases:
http://en.wikipedia.beta.wmflabs.org/wiki/Topic:Sl18xph3p9den4ob (deleted topic)
mw.flow.data.blocks.topic has no 'roots'.
http://en.wikipedia.beta.wmflabs.org/wiki/Topic:Sl18xaj7bextx9g8 (non deleted topic)
mw.flow.data.blocks.topic has 'roots'
The first one retur … ission to view; as a result, the topic is not rendered (and the DM shou … to the data model and render it.
still use the permission system (which e.g. also checks if page is deleted, for example)
Pretty sure none o … where I needed to fill out view-topic-summary after starting to check for those permissions.
onverted_to_Flow| LQT page converted to Flow]]}} but does nothing.)
Split off from T114043#1698940:
If you view a preview of a deleted board through the Special:Undele … flow_topiclist_loop.partial"]
```
rocess caching, we should be able to eliminate hundreds of queries.
anchor is encoded properly. See [[ https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Tesyta6rspc1pysm | Topic:Tesyta6rspc1pysm ]] for a test.
… w:Wikipedia:Sandbox?action=edit]`
ecial:Nuke - the empty Flow page won't be displayed on the list.
edia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Quiddity_%28WMF%29&action=history )
1. On a Flow board topic create a link.
2. Open the link … pector does not work.
{F4096349}
lly possible to massive rollback from Contribs page or using Nuke.
012; 3.4.5.6; 4.5.6.7]
13:32 . . (+13) . . 1.2.3.4 (talk)
ki | DB://cluster24/73361200 | external | post | restore-topic | 050c20d42af53cafb69678 |
… | external | post | delete-topic | 052b828fc3ab055935412d | … | external | post | delete-topic | 052b828fe077055935412d | … | external | post | delete-topic | 052b828feacf055935412d | … | external | post | delete-topic | 052b828ff77f055935412d | … | external | post | delete-…